Politicolor Header Image

The Creativity Deficit

To my educator friends: when we are confronted by colleagues who feel that drill, rote memorization, and standardized testing is the default position for education reform, we need to make them read this article:

The Creativity Crisis on Newsweek.com

Read the whole article but here’s a clip to consider the scope of the problem…

Like intelligence tests, Torrance’s test—a 90-minute series of discrete tasks, administered by a psychologist—has been taken by millions worldwide in 50 languages. Yet there is one crucial difference between IQ and CQ scores. With intelligence, there is a phenomenon called the Flynn effect—each generation, scores go up about 10 points. Enriched environments are making kids smarter. With creativity, a reverse trend has just been identified and is being reported for the first time here: American creativity scores are falling.

See Like Cicero

After last year’s National Academy, we shared Cicero’s View from 100,000 Miles. He will make his more formal appearance at this year’s National Academy in the morning. Found this video on the Hayden Planetarium’s site and it provides all the perspective to think like Cicero. To think big… and small!

YouTube Preview Image

Teaching from Montpelier

Teachers & the Temple

Adjusting to the real world after a week at Montpelier can be challenging. There are real pressures to be ready for the next school year but an equally real mission to teach the substance of the ideas present in our curriculum. Several participants have shared their gratitude via e-mail or the Facebook group. I wanted to share those ideas here and invite you to add your own thoughts.

Whether you left Montpelier last week or two years ago, how will you use it to super charge your teaching?

Sherry Willis wrote this poem to commemorate our time together. I especially like that last line…

They came from everywhere all across this great land
…West coast, east coast, the north, and the south
Dark hair, light hair, young and mature
All thrown into the Madision melting pot
Scholar, teacher, and student
Listening, discussing, thinking, and learning
All in the Madision way
Laughing, walking, feasting, and fellowshiping
Honoring not only the man but the work he had done
Revived, renewed patriotism and passion
Diverse yet joined in the Spirit of the Union that is greater than themselves

The James Madison Workshop June 20-25, 2010

From the second week, Paige forwarded her thoughts on the week by e-mail:

I realized to an even greater extent than before that we really have to find the time to focus more on the founding using primary source documents.  Perhaps by empowering our students with that “maker’s knowledge” we can best fight the cynicism and lack of political efficacy that seem so prevalent today.

Works in progress are welcome too… so, alumni from previous years, tell us what you did and how it worked.

Big Feet

One of the commitments of the Politicolor community is making complex ideas accessible. This rendition of carbon footprints attempts to do just that. If the U.S. doesn’t take the lead, who else can fill those shoes?

Carbon Footprints

Seeing America

The second week at Montpelier concluded Friday with this question… What do you SEE when you say AMERICA?

As the American public celebrates independence through fireworks, BBQ and pool parties, the 80 teachers who studied constitutional citizenship at Madison’s Montpelier know we must keep the future as well as the past in our mind’s eye. There’s no reason to skip the fireworks but let’s consider what that particular moment in time reveals to us about our present and our future. If America is an idea rather than a place, it’s essential that we share our ideas about what America is or could be.

It’s that mission that led to our last assignment for our afternoon discussion. We focused on our work as teachers and the role of citizens and elected representatives as constitutional officers, and Jim LeCain shared a quote he thought defined our mission:

Teach the [Constitution's] principles, teach them to your children, speak of them when sitting in your home, speak of them when walking by the way, when lying down and when rising up, write them upon the doorplate of your home and upon your gates.

–John Quincy Adams on the 50th anniversary of the U.S. Constitution

–Quoted by Chief Justice Warren Burger at the 200th anniversary celebration

The quote resonates with the power of the words in Deuteronomy beginning with 6:5:

Love the LORD your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your strength. 6 These commandments that I give you today are to be upon your hearts. 7 Impress them on your children. Talk about them when you sit at home and when you walk along the road, when you lie down and when you get up. 8 Tie them as symbols on your hands and bind them on your foreheads. 9 Write them on the doorframes of your houses and on your gates.

And Will couldn’t stop there. If you didn’t hear the cadence of the words in Deuteronomy when you read the quote, you might have remembered a folk anthem instead. Remember these lyrics from Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young’s “Teach Your Children”…

You, who are on the road
Must have a code
That you can live by.
And so, become yourself
Because the past
Is just a goodbye.

Teach, your children well
Their father’s hell
Did slowly go by
And feed them on your dreams
The one they pick’s
The one you’ll know by.
Don’t you ever ask them why
If they told you, you would die
So just look at them and sigh
And know they love you.

With such an important task at hand, what do you SEE when you say AMERICA?

Weekly Wavelength

This is one of the easiest ways to share your ideas on Politicolor. Every week we ask our contributors two questions and post their answers in an effort to help you find good ideas on the web.

What didn’t you know last week?

Facts from the The Time Magazine article linked below… the law creating the Federal Trade Commission was 8 pages; The Social Security Act was 28 pages; The conference version of the financial reform bill 2,319 pages (Keith/K2)

So what I found interesting this week was what the presidency meant to certain individuals, and what they’d do if president. Really interesting to consider in light of the discussion at Montpelier regarding Madison’s conception of the office and how it relates to our modern understanding of the executive office. (Heidi)

That James Madison never traveled on a boat – except maybe to cross the Long Island Sound. So says Ralph Ketcham, THE Madison biographer. (Shayne/Conteach)

Civil War reenactors take Fredericksburg so seriously that they’ll lie dead on someone’s lawn all day when *shot*. (Keith/Hobbes21)

McChrystal should pursue his future in the pages of a comic book. I had to read the Rolling Stone article for myself and now have to admit I sometimes enjoyed the mythology built up around this guy. (Shellee/Stepwinder)

What are you reading?

Time magazine article-The Best Laws Money Can Buy; The article is about the work of lobbyists in Washington.  Last year $3.5 billion was spent on lobbyists in D.C. (the biggest bargain in town is the subtitle of the article), no mention of how much was spent when you add in all of the state governments.  The question that the article makes you think about is, do lobbyists help the system work or are they just buying off the system for large corporations?  One proud lobbyist in the article states, “I think lobbyists provide input that makes the system work better.”  Another person in the article recommends a Constitutional amendment stripping for profit corporations of their first amendment rights.  What is the proper role for lobbyists?  Is this simply petitioning the government or is it corrupting the system?  Is the root of the problem the always increasing costs of running for office? (Keith/K2)

Revolutionaries by Jack Rakove; It’s providing some great insights into not only the individual men of the American Revolution, but the different circumstances within each colony that encouraged and sometimes forced the founders to become revolutionaries. (Heidi)

A piece about what we cannot know about Wilson’s illness at the end of his presidency. It does seem that Edith Wilson and those surrounding her were not thinking about the good of the country. (Shayne/Conteach)

Straight from the reading list at Montpelier’s Institute… Federalist 39, the Virginia Declaration of Rights and the Debates on the Bill of Rights. (Keith/Hobbes21).

The Wisdom of Crowds; The author takes a page from Aristotle when he says large groups of people are smarter than an elite few. This is my latest effort at cultivating an audiobook habit. Not sure it’s going to stick… guess we’ll see how much I remember when I finish listening to this one! (Shellee/Stepwinder)

The Next 100

We’ve passed a mile marker… 100 posts on Politicolor. This site represents a lot of heavy thinking from within the classroom as well as from the world writ large. The richness of ideas presented here speaks to the communities of scholars created for brief moments in either Los Angeles or Orange, Virginia. While those events inevitably reach a conclusion, the surplus of mind lingers to provoke each of us to imagine what it means to be a teacher and a citizen who takes seriously our commitment to a larger constitutional order.

Sharing ideas powered those offline communities as much as it fuels discussions here. We hope you’ll find a way to share your ideas in the next 100 posts. Tech guru Chris Brogan recently contemplated how sharing matters online. He organized his ideas around two propositions… sharing moves information more effectively and adds value to the larger tapestry. A guru from another era suggested freedom itself requires us to exercise our minds so they venture abroad and contemplate what lies beyond. Whether you take your cues from the world of tech or the dream of Scipio, here are some of our top posts for thinking richly, broadly and creatively.

*****

You can make this a conversation by sharing your thoughts as a reply in the comments section on this post or any of the others. If you’d like to join us as a regular contributor, drop that note in the comments and we’ll let you know how to get started.

The Essential Declaration

I was a little late discovering this project but it’s perfect for alumni of either NEH institute. Slate is asking the public to express the most essential idea of the Declaration of Independence on Twitter. Can you boil it down to 124 characters or less? Post your ideas as comments here and we’ll tweet them through @Politicolor over the holiday weekend. Use this link to see what the people of the Twitterverse are doing with the proposition too.

Weekly Wavelength

The summer circuit has begun. A few of our regular contributors are on their way to Orange, Virginia for the NEH Landmarks Institute at Madison’s Montpelier. So, I’m finally posting this today courtesy of free wifi at Hyperion Coffee in Fredericksburg. Here’s what your favorite group of civic-minded thinkers are thinking this week:

What didn’t you know last week?

Last week I knew almost nothing about World Cup Soccer. Now I know more and I feel so much more worldly and I’ve had great conversations with people from all over the world that I run into at the store or working at restaurants. Very fun. Here’s a great link to help the American sports fan understand something about the 32 teams in the Cup. (Shayne/Conteach)

This week I learned from that Fa Mulan, of Disney’s Mulan  fame, was probably an historical character, a real “Woman Warrior,” as Maxine Hong Kingston has it, who rode out to fight against China’s enemies.  Eddie Murphy did not, however, voice the spirits of her ancestors (as far as we know.) (Dianne)

There’s a Frank Lloyd Wright House in Alexandria, Virginia. You can now tour the Pope Leighey House on the grounds of the Woodlawn Plantation. It was originally built in Falls Church. (Heidi)

A team at Moon Zoo is attempting the capitalize on the power of the wired world to study the craters on the moon. Create a login and you can contribute to the effort too. The information you provide will help researchers determine the age of the craters and the history of the moon.

What are you reading?

The Servile State by Hilaire Belloc, and Everything’s an Argument by Andrea Lunsford, et al. (Laura/Puck/Puckermom)

Noah Pickus adds his work to the effort at Montpelier with a lecture titled “Constitutional Citizenship” and I always leave that institute determined to read his book. Well, I finally made it happen this round and I highly recommend True Faith and Allegiance by Noah Pickus. I have a more detailed post planned for the next couple of weeks looking at the five models of citizenship he discusses. (Shellee/Stepwinder)

A few of us are still working on Ralph Ketcham’s biography of James Madison. A thorough but incredibly well-written book that skillfully answers questions about both the political history and political theory of Madison. (Heidi)

Using the oil spill to discuss the modern presidency as one of perception (or illusion), Obama, the Oil Spill and the Chaos Perception in the NY Times. (Shellee/Stepwinder)

It’s the end of the Supreme Court’s term and decisions are being handed down almost everyday. Scotusblog is a great place to learn what’s been decided and to read commentary about the implications of the decisions. Today I am reading about the texting privacy case City of Ontario v. Quon. (Shayne/Conteach)

I just finished Grace Tiffany’s The Turquoise Ring.  It’s her retelling of  The Merchant of Venice from the perspective of five women in Shiloh (Shylock)’s life.  My fiance brought it back from a conference of medieval historians and it’s a fascinating peek into the lives of Jews, Moors, and Christians in Venice, Amsterdam, and England in the 1500s.  Dr. Tiffany is a Shakespeare scholar who lives in Michigan and who spoke at the conference. (Dianne)

************
You can make this a conversation by leaving your thoughts on any of the ideas shared here as a reply in the comments section. If you’d like to join us as a regular contributor to the Wavelength, drop that note in the comments and you’ll hear from me before we post next week’s collection.

Weekly Wavelength

Summer vacation has either started or is very near for most of our contributors in the classroom. I think it shows in the diversity of ideas shared this week–including student portfolios!

What didn’t you know last week?

Great in-depth reporting by NPR and ProPublica about Traumatic Brain Injury from Afghanistan and Iraq and the lack of care available to vets. (Shayne/Conteach)

The North Korean government devalued the currency last November to save the state-run economy while devastating families who had managed to save money. I didn’t know this impoverished economy also forced the country to abandon a full school day. Students go to school for as much of the morning as they can stand. A former teacher says many of her students were too hungry to study. This New York Times article provides haunting details of daily life in North Korea. (Shellee/Stepwinder)

Dear Abby was a supporter of Gay Rights.  Not that she was marching in Pride Parades but she was always supportive in her columns in the 70′s and 80′s and received quite a bit of hate mail as a result. (K-Rod/Kerryn)

The President is proposing a potential reconstruction of nature and society… WOAH. Definitely something I didn’t know last week. But how can he legislatively do something at this level? Maybe only in theory… Could Obama Really move the Mississippi to Save the Wetlands?. (Heidi) **That’s a crazy interesting site too. They just picked up a Twitter follower while I was checking the link.**

How many places there are to stub a toe or bump your head on a WWII submarine, or how cool parents can be when you stay up all night with them on a field trip. (Keith/Hobbes21)

The word “plutoed” was selected by the American Dialect Society as the word of the year in 2006.  In that statement I learned a couple of things:

1. The word “plutoed” (meaning–To demote or devalue someone or something, as happened to Pluto when it lost planet status),
2. There is an American Dialect Society.

On a side note, less than 5% of the world’s astronomers voted on that issue. (K2/Bookworm20/Keith)

What are you reading?

Actually mostly listening, but… NPR’s Planet Money podcast. It was great at reporting on the financial crisis and it continues to provide very clear economics reporting. (Shayne/Conteach)

I’m trying to make a commitment to “longform journalism” to diversify my reading on the web, and I have every intention of reading “Your Brain on Computers: Hooked on Technology, and Paying a Mental Price.” The author of “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” in The Atlantic has published a book on the topic so a number of newspapers and magazines are talking about this. I know they’re all talking about it but I can’t tell you what they’re saying because I haven’t made the time to read the whole article! (Shellee/Stepwinder)

Making Gay History by Eric Marcus . Great book.  Easy read, told through personal stories and accounts of what was happening from the folks that made it happen. (K-Rod/Kerryn)

Reading the required stuff for MontP. James Madison IS a “Champion of Liberty and Justice! From that list, Ralph Ketcham has written an incredible biography of James Madison. (Heidi)

Student writing portfolios, Ketcham’s Madison biography (Keith/Hobbes21)

Unscientific America: How Scientific Illiteracy Threatens Our Future
This book looks at the disconnect between the scientific community and mainstream American society. The oil spill, oil drilling, and energy policy are perfect examples of how important scientific understanding are for policy decisions and yet how little attention is often given to the subject of science in our society. (K2/Bookworm20/Keith)

******

You can make this a conversation by leaving your thoughts on any of the ideas shared here as a reply in the comments section. If you’d like to join us as a regular contributor to the Wavelength, drop that note in the comments and you’ll hear from me before we post next week’s collection.